Wednesday, September 3, 2025

SearchResearch Challenge (9/3/25): What kind of art is this?

 While wandering around downtown Lucerne, Switzerland... 

A section of the painting showing the disarmament of the soldiers. P/C Wikimedia


... I came across a really interesting building.  It was clearly an old building in a regular polygonal shape--looks like a hexadecagon (16 sides).  It's obviously been embedded within a fairly square modernist building.  

P/C Dan--captured from Google Maps satellite view

I went inside and found a completely remarkable painting of an important event in Swiss history--the internment of the French Armée de l'Est in neutral Switzerland at the end of the 1870–71 Franco-Prussian War.  (Note: in this case, "internment" doesn't mean being an intern for the summer, but rather describe a neutral country detaining belligerent armed forces and equipment on its territory during times of war, under the Hague Convention of 1907.)   

The thing is... the painting is huge, and in the round--it takes your breath away, it's that dramatic.  

You enter into the center of the vista from below and are immediately surrounded by a 360-degree view.  It's a 19th century version of VR.  In a world without movies, videos, 3D computer graphics, virtual reality, or augmented reality headsets, it was the closest thing you could get to being there in the middle of the action.  

Being in the middle of this circular painting reminded me that I'd visited another, similar installation a few years ago--although that visit was somewhere in the eastern United States.  But, I wondered, where would I have seen something like this? 

This makes a great SearchResearch Challenge for the week.  

1. What is this kind of art installation called?  

2. Are there any of these giant 360-degree paintings still in use somewhere in the US?  (If so, where? Any in the eastern US still around?)  

3. How many of these things have survived from the 19th century into modern times?  (And... is there one you can visit near me?) 

4. What was the effect of this internment on the development of Switzerland?  Why was it such an important event?  

The first 3 Challenges are pretty straight-forward, while the last one calls for a bit more thinking.  

As always, let us know how you found the answers.  (If you just know off the top of your head, that's fine, just say so.  If you called your favorite Swiss historian, let us know that as well.) 

But please share your method with us!  

Keep searching!  



18 comments:

  1. With [hexadecagon building Switzerland Lucerne with 360 painting]

    Some good results

    Panorama...Their inventor was the British painter Robert Barker, who patented this new medium in 1787, and himself painted a 360-degree picture of Edinburgh.

    https://www.bourbakipanorama.ch/en/museum/circular-painting/


    With [SearchResearch Challenge (9/3/25): What kind of art is this?
    While wandering around downtown Lucerne, Switzerland... ] AI summary mentioned some parts of Switzerland so I learned. No the wanted one. The Lion monument, one of the mentioned

    The link to the Lion
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lion_Monument
    Mark Twain connection

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tried finding Panoramas in Mexico. Just some beautiful Mural. And virtual visits to Museum.

      Then [list of similar paintings to Bourbaki Panorama]

      International Panorama Council. A database.

      https://panoramacouncil.org/en/what_we_do/resources/panoramas_and_related_art_forms_database/?display_all

      Panoramas in Switzerland

      https://panoramacouncil.org/en/what_we_do/resources/panoramas_and_related_art_forms_database/?type=360&country=switzerland&search=

      Panoramas in the United States
      https://panoramacouncil.org/en/what_we_do/resources/panoramas_and_related_art_forms_database/?type=360&country=united_states_of_america&search=


      [difference between panorama and cyclorama]

      Delete
    2. With [the internment of the French Armée de l'Est in neutral Switzerland importance for Switzerland history]

      The birth of humanitarian Switzerland


      Why is the internment of these soldiers such a significant event in Swiss history?

      https://www.post.ch/en/about-us/news/2021/it-was-the-birth-of-humanitarian-switzerland

      Delete
  2. Thanks for another great challenge Dr. Russell.

    This immediately sounded familiar. I remembered visiting one close to me in the Hirshhorn Museum of Modern Art by an artist named Mark Bradford. While the Hirshhorn is a round building, the artwork must be walked around the wall to appreciate. There isn't a way to view it from the center as the building is a donut shape.

    Looking that up reminded me that I had also been to Gettysburg and seen the artwork by Paul Philippoteaux. Both artworks gave me the vocabulary word for that type of art installation. While reading results on the previous two, it was mentioned about another installation of this type in Georgia.

    1. I found this by reading descriptions for the two I had visited.

    2. At least three of these are here in the east: D.C., Pennsylvania, and Georgia.

    3. I Google searched for a list of this type of installation, and Wikipedia came through with a list of surviving examples. I couldn't find any current art installations of this type unless you include the immersive mirror installation Yayoi Kusama: Dreaming of Earth’s Sphericity, I Would Offer My Love. The San Francisco Museum of Modern Art has had previous one though.

    4. I used three different AI tools - Perplexity, Google Search AI (not Gemini), and Duck.ai (chatgpt 4.0). I used the same phrase for all three: "Explain it to me like I'm a 5th grader. Why was the internment of the French Armée de l'Est in neutral Switzerland at the end of the 1870–71 Franco-Prussian War important in Swiss history?"

    ReplyDelete
  3. fwiw: cyclorama is a more specific term...
    "Yes, Switzerland is officially a neutral country, a status established in 1815 by the Congress of Vienna. Its neutrality is defined as "armed neutrality," meaning it maintains a strong military for self-defense but does not participate in foreign wars.

    However, there have been times when its actions have been viewed as a deviation from strict neutrality:

    World War II: Switzerland maintained trade with Nazi Germany, which some historians argue prolonged the war. It also had a controversial policy of turning away Jewish refugees at its borders and later faced scrutiny for holding assets looted by the Nazis in Swiss banks.


    Sanctions against Russia: Following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, Switzerland broke with its long-standing tradition of only adopting sanctions imposed by the UN Security Council and instead adopted sanctions from the European Union against Russia."

    and they do provide partial security to the Pope/Vatican City

    Gemini overview:
    "Panoramic paintings, including the 360-degree cyclorama and the scrolling moving panorama, can be viewed at museums across the United States. While only a few 19th-century originals survive, they offer an immersive window into historical events and landscapes.
    Cycloramas
    A cyclorama is a massive, curved, 360-degree painting that surrounds the viewer, often enhanced with light, sound effects, and a three-dimensional foreground to create an immersive experience.
    The Battle of Atlanta (Atlanta, GA): This fully restored 1886 painting is housed in a custom-built facility at the Atlanta History Center. Visitors stand on a stationary platform as the painting is brought to life with a multimedia presentation. It is one of only two Civil War cycloramas in the U.S.
    The Battle of Gettysburg (Gettysburg, PA): The 1883 painting of Pickett's Charge is the other Civil War cyclorama in the U.S. It is on display at the Gettysburg National Military Park Museum & Visitor Center and includes a diorama foreground and sound and light effects.
    Velaslavasay Panorama (Los Angeles, CA): This venue is dedicated to the exhibition of panoramas and provides rotating installations. Current and past works include the Panorama of the Valley of the Smokes and Effulgence of the North.
    Moving panoramas
    A moving panorama is a long, continuous painting on a spool that is cranked horizontally across a stage. They were a popular form of entertainment in the 19th century, simulating a journey for the seated audience.
    Panorama of the Monumental Grandeur of the Mississippi Valley (St. Louis, MO): This is the only known surviving moving panorama of the Mississippi River. Commissioned around 1850, it is made of distemper on cotton muslin and depicts historical and archaeological sites. The work is owned by the St. Louis Art Museum, which has a video of the restored panorama rolling on its website. It is not currently on public display.
    Grand Panorama of a Whaling Voyage 'Round the World (New Bedford, MA, and traveling): This 1,275-foot-long painting is the longest in the U.S. Originally a moving panorama, it is now owned by the New Bedford Whaling Museum. It travels to other institutions, where it is often displayed in a stationary formation. The museum also offers special "advancement day" events to see the painting in motion. The Minnesota Marine Art Museum is hosting an exhibition of the panorama in 2025. "

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panoramic_painting#:~:text=The%20Rac%C5%82awice%20Panorama%2C%20currently%20located,on%20display%20at%20Mamayev%20Kurgan.
    https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna43241271
    https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/360-degrees-of-war-6-cycloramas-that-make-you-a-part-of-the-action

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. regarding the Swiss Guard -
      https://blog.nationalmuseum.ch/en/2023/05/the-darkest-day-in-the-history-of-the-swiss-guard/

      Delete
  4. thought of "The Sphere" in Las Vegas...? kinda not...
    "No, a projected image on the inside of the Las Vegas Sphere would not be considered a painting, although it can be a panorama. The distinction depends on the fundamental nature of the artwork: whether it is created by applying a medium to a surface or by projecting light onto one.
    Projected image vs. painting
    Painting: A painting is a work of visual art created by the application of physical materials, like paint or ink, onto a solid surface, such as a canvas, wall, or wood. The artwork is a tangible object that exists independently of a projection.
    Projected image: An image projected onto a surface is made of light, not physical pigments. For example, the Sphere's interior uses a massive LED screen, which projects images but is not a canvas with paint applied to it.
    Panoramic projection vs. panoramic painting
    The artwork in the Sphere would be considered a panorama, but a panoramic projection, not a panoramic painting.
    Panoramic Painting Panoramic Projection
    Medium Physical pigments applied to a large, cylindrical canvas. Digital images created with software and displayed using projectors or LEDs.
    Historical context Originating in the late 18th century, these large-scale canvases were designed to create an immersive, all-around view for spectators. A modern technological evolution of the panoramic concept, replacing static canvases with dynamic digital displays.
    Form A massive, tangible object that spectators view from a central platform. An immaterial display of light that can be manipulated to create the illusion of a vast environment."

    https://www.holobuilder.com/content-type/article/360-photo-vs-photo-sphere-vs-panorama-whats-the-difference/

    ReplyDelete
  5. in Toronto - from cyclorama/panorama to parking garage to rental car depot to oblivion... (series of images) such is the fate of the cutting edge/future... 1887-1976
    https://www.instagram.com/p/C_27bBxNKcV/
    https://www.blogto.com/city/2012/01/a_brief_history_of_the_cyclorama_building_in_toronto/
    https://thebridgenews.ca/torontos-cyclorama-building/
    https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cyclorama_Toronto_circa_1922.jpg

    meanwhile, in Lucerne...
    outside:
    https://i.imgur.com/WWZ6FN5.jpeg
    inside: (Swiss 'stealth weapon' ;^P)
    https://i.imgur.com/PiiQ4p9.jpeg
    https://i.imgur.com/PiiQ4p9.jpeg

    cyclorama - not to be confused with a cyclotron...
    also visiting oblivion...
    (a little alumni nod to IUB)
    https://ceem.indiana.edu/about/history/iu-cyclotron-facility-1976-2010.html
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_University_Health_Proton_Therapy_Center
    https://ceem.indiana.edu/index.html
    https://ceem.indiana.edu/about/history/cooler-storage-ring.html


    ReplyDelete
  6. I see that Sutterstock saya it has over 113+ thousand panorama images for us. Still a popular thing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. There is the Cyclorama in Atlanta: https://www.atlantahistorycenter.com/exhibitions/cyclorama/ and the Gettysburg Cyclorama: https://www.nps.gov/gett/learn/historyculture/cyclorama.htm are 2 I know of picturing Civil War Battles. I've gotten to visit both and they are amazing works of art that you can spend a long time examining.

    ReplyDelete
  8. this would be close to you - and on the West Coast... if it existed and wasn't hypothetical...
    Google going retro while springboarding into the future...

    Una perspectiva de evolutione machinarum inquisitoriarum dum interrete et ultra occupant... Intellegentia Artificialis
    (hard to capture the full grandeur photographically)
    https://i.imgur.com/BsCZoJl.jpeg
    https://i.imgur.com/E0s421n.jpeg
    https://i.imgur.com/uKfEbTI.jpeg
    https://i.imgur.com/eS7ooLk.jpeg
    https://i.imgur.com/CuEJFA1.jpeg

    and I think I imagined admission would be 25¢., similar to Toronto, back in the day
    and with a small nod to Lucerne, basilisk and the Sorcerer's apprentice...
    The painting/panorama is constantly being updated/revised by the AI staff and
    credentialed humans... (some of the robots are sporting berets... one supposedly uttered,
    "what fresh meatbag hell is this?")

    ReplyDelete
  9. thought the painted ceiling of the Sistine Chapel might qualify as an early panorama forerunner -
    just a different orientation... made me consider the many painted domes and ran across the following examp
    Palazzo Te, Mantua, Italy
    room of giants... immersive
    https://youtu.be/q3JZC_XxeXQ?si=iSt3J2KLzOfs5m9_&t=204
    the Gemini overview:
    "If we're talking about true, hemispherical domes, then another strong contender for "most famous" would be the dome of St. Peter's Basilica, also in the Vatican, with its stunning mosaic decorations and inscriptions, though it's more architectural than a single painted narrative.
    However, if we strictly adhere to a single painted dome, some others rise to immense fame:

    Here are some other famous painted dome ceilings around the world:

    St. Peter's Basilica, Vatican City: While the Sistine Chapel ceiling is a vault, St. Peter's dome itself is magnificent. It features intricate mosaics and a Latin inscription proclaiming Peter as the Rock of the Church, designed by Michelangelo and completed by Giacomo della Porta. It's a marvel of both architecture and decorative art.

    Florence Cathedral (Duomo), Florence, Italy: The interior of Brunelleschi's iconic dome is painted with a monumental fresco of the Last Judgment by Giorgio Vasari and Federico Zuccari. This is a very strong contender for "most famous painted dome" in its own right, known for its dramatic scale and detail.


    Pantheon, Rome, Italy: While its famous oculus lets in natural light and it's largely unpainted on the inside, the Pantheon's colossal dome is historically one of the most significant and awe-inspiring domes in the world. It's an example where the architectural form itself is the primary visual spectacle.

    Church of the Gesù, Rome, Italy: The dome features the breathtaking fresco "Triumph of the Name of Jesus" by Giovanni Battista Gaulli (Baciccio). It's a masterpiece of Baroque illusionism, where figures seem to burst out of the architectural confines and ascend into heaven.


    St. Paul's Cathedral, London, England: The interior of the dome is adorned with frescoes depicting the Life of St Paul by Sir James Thornhill. Its grandeur is a key feature of the famous London landmark.

    Hagia Sophia, Istanbul, Turkey: Originally a Christian basilica, then a mosque, and now a museum, the Hagia Sophia's dome is famous for its vastness and surviving Byzantine mosaics, particularly the Christ Pantocrator (Ruler of All) in the apse, and remnants of what would have been magnificent dome mosaics.


    Palazzo Te, Mantua, Italy (Chamber of the Giants): While not a traditional dome, the entire room, including the ceiling, is painted with a single, overwhelming fresco by Giulio Romano depicting the Fall of the Giants. It creates an incredible illusion of the room collapsing around the viewer, functioning much like an immersive panoramic experience, even in its smaller scale."

    ReplyDelete
  10. and there is this... best viewed on your back, on a turn table?
    https://www.aoc.gov/explore-capitol-campus/art/apotheosis-washington
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Apotheosis_of_Washington
    some other domestic examples:
    "The most famous painted church ceiling or dome in the United States is arguably the dome of the Library of Congress Thomas Jefferson Building in Washington D.C., specifically the Great Hall and its dome.

    While not a church in the traditional sense, the Library of Congress, with its grand Beaux-Arts architecture and highly symbolic and allegorical artwork, functions as a kind of civic cathedral. Its main reading room and the Great Hall are immensely famous for their painted ceilings and dome.

    The dome and pendentives of the Great Hall feature stunning murals by Edwin Blashfield, depicting allegorical figures representing various fields of human thought and knowledge. These murals, along with the other ornate decorations, make it an iconic example of painted ceilings in America.

    Other notable examples of painted church ceilings or domes in the U.S. include:

    Cathedral Basilica of Saint Louis, St. Louis, Missouri: This cathedral boasts one of the largest mosaic collections in the world, with its domes and ceilings entirely covered in intricate mosaics depicting biblical scenes and saints. It's truly breathtaking.

    Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception, Washington D.C.: As the largest Catholic church in North America, its multiple domes and vast ceilings are adorned with extensive mosaics and paintings depicting Marian themes, saints, and pivotal moments in Catholic history.

    St. Patrick's Cathedral, New York City, New York: While not as extensively painted as some European cathedrals, its vaulted ceilings feature beautiful decorative patterns and some intricate details that contribute to its grandeur and recognition as a major American church.

    Church of the Transfiguration, Orleans, Massachusetts (Community of Jesus): This lesser-known but exceptionally beautiful church features a stunning contemporary fresco cycle in the Byzantine style, including its large dome. The artwork is truly magnificent and covers the entire interior.

    While there might not be a single "American Sistine Chapel" with the same level of global recognition, the dome of the Library of Congress and the mosaics of the St. Louis Cathedral Basilica are definitely among the most celebrated and visually impactful painted ceilings/domes in the United States."
    "The painting inside the eye of the U.S. Capitol Rotunda dome is titled "The Apotheosis of Washington" and was painted by Constantino Brumidi in 1865.

    ReplyDelete
  11. asked Gemini about most recent examples...
    "The most recent example of a large, publicly accessible, purpose-built cyclorama panorama painting that has garnered significant attention and is considered a contemporary work is the Gettysburg Cyclorama itself, after its extensive and faithful restoration and relocation in 2008.

    While the painting itself was completed in 1884, the 2008 project was a monumental undertaking that essentially brought it back to its original glory and created a state-of-the-art viewing experience. This involved:

    Massive Restoration: The painting, which had been cut, folded, and stored poorly over the decades, underwent a multi-year, multi-million-dollar restoration process to repair tears, remove previous overpainting, and bring back its original colors and details.

    Relocation and New Building: It was moved from an inadequate circular building to a purpose-built, climate-controlled rotunda within the new Gettysburg National Military Park Museum & Visitor Center.

    Re-creation of Original Presentation: Crucially, the 2008 re-installation meticulously recreated the original 1880s viewing experience, including the 3D diorama in front of the painting, strategic lighting, and an elevated viewing platform.

    So, while the painting's creation date is historical, its 2008 restoration and re-installation represents the most significant and recent effort to present a classic cyclorama panorama to the public as a fully immersive and accurate historical experience. It essentially represents a modern "rebirth" of a traditional cyclorama, making it a highly relevant "recent example" in terms of its public presentation and renewed cultural impact.

    Beyond that specific restoration, here are some other recent or contemporary panorama/cyclorama-style artistic endeavors that push the boundaries:

    https://www.red-dot.org/de/project/carolas-garden-54849
    Yadegar Asisi's Panoramas: German artist Yadegar Asisi is the most prominent contemporary artist dedicated to creating massive 360-degree panoramas. He has produced numerous works in cities like Leipzig, Berlin, and Dresden, often housed in purpose-built rotundas (like the Panometer Leipzig, Panometer Dresden). His themes range from ancient Rome ("Rome 312") to natural wonders ("Great Barrier Reef") and historical events ("Die Mauer" - The Berlin Wall). These are new paintings/installations, not restorations of old ones.


    "Carola's Garden" (2024, Leipzig): His latest opening as of early 2024, depicting a bee's perspective on a garden.

    Digital Panoramas and VR: While not "paintings" in the traditional sense, the concept of immersive panoramas is thriving in digital art and virtual reality. Artists and developers are creating fully encompassing digital environments that surround the viewer, drawing heavily on the principles established by physical panoramas. These are "recent" in their continuous innovation.

    So, if you're looking for a physical painting that is a modern creation, Yadegar Asisi's work is the leading example. If you consider the faithful re-creation and presentation of a historic work as a "recent example" of the experience, then the 2008 Gettysburg Cyclorama relaunch is also very significant."

    ReplyDelete
  12. includes audio for more immersion... CAROLA’S GARDEN is a 32-metre-high panorama by the artist Yadegar Asisi
    https://vimeo.com/609650275?fl=pl&fe=ti

    ReplyDelete
  13. in New York:
    https://www.dw.com/en/new-york-9-11-yadegar-asisis-new-panorama/video-61488510

    ReplyDelete
  14. Asisi - contemporary practitioner -
    Artist Yadegar Asisi
    https://www.asisi.de/en/homepage
    https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yadegar_Asisi
    in Switzerland -
    https://www.instagram.com/p/DKUljK5svmU/

    ReplyDelete
  15. electronic immersive - London - first time I've heard of it -
    maybe you have visited?
    https://www.outernet.com/
    https://www.instagram.com/OuternetGlobal

    ReplyDelete