Monday, January 20, 2014

Answer: What's up with her fingers?

Sorry about the delay in answering.  Friday sometimes turns out to be too busy!  


I brought up this Search Challenge about the "webbing" between the fingers because it's the kind of question that students often ask.  "Why is <this thing> like <that>??"  It's a natural kind of curiosity, because, as you've seen, any sculptor of Bernini's talent wouldn't have just left the webbing there by accident.  Or... would he? 

As everyone figured out (most simply by doing image search), this is Bernini's "La Verità"(in Italian) or "Truth Unveiled by Time."  It was  begun in 1645, after the death of Pope Urban VIII.  This woman was supposed to be the personification of Truth, part of a larger statue that would have included a personification of Time (probably an old man) who would have been lifting off the veil (which is why that drapery is going so far up into the sky--Time is supposed to be holding it up). 


The sculpture was made when Bernini was going through a tough time at the papal court.  There was a little incident of another one of his bell tower apparently causing structural problems at St. Peter's Basilica.  (Never really proven, but it didn't make his life any easier. They tore his work down, worried that if it fell, it would take large pieces of the Basilica with it.)  

A slightly different view showing the webbing between fingers, thumb and body, and between rays of the sun's disk.


The consequence is that the statue is apparently unfinished.  It was a turbulent time, and for whatever reason, completing this work never made the top of his to-do list.  

For me, the question was "what about that webbing in-between her fingers?

I did a bunch of obvious searches that didn't get me very far.  

     [ Bernini statue webbing fingers ] 

In short, the use of the word "webbing" just wasn't getting me anywhere.  Given the number of art history books, journals, and articles out there, I couldn't believe that I was the first person to notice this.  I knew there had to be an explanation out there:  I just needed to figure out what the art historians would call this.  

To find the right term, I decided to NOT focus on Bernini, but try to figure out what the word (or phrase)  for "the stone left between fingers by the sculptor."  I was thinking it might be an Italian term that I just didn't know, so by asking a more general question I was hoping to figure out the term.  

My next query was: 

     [ sculpture stone between fingers ] 

And there, in the 3rd position was the "Bernini Struts" article by Michael Cole.   In this search, I got really lucky.  Not only did I learn that the word I was looking for is struts, but the article is explicitly about struts by Bernini!  

Cole writes a bit about the process of sculpting: 
"After drilling through the stone, the sculptor would then hollow out the area with a rasping file (raspa) or small chisel (scalpello), leaving a series of struts or bridges in place to brace the stone while he worked. Only when the hand was finished would these struts be cut away. The fact that many sculptures survive with such struts still intact indicates that their removal was among the last things the sculptor would do on the work, presumably in the interest of keeping the figure’s most fragile parts protected, even while other areas of the statue were being carved. It also suggests that sculptors who had once planned for hands arranged in dramatic poses sometimes lost their nerve, deciding that a seemingly ‘‘non-finito’’ statue was preferable to one with replaced or added fingers, arms, or legs."

Here we learn another technical term, "non-finito" (unfinished), and it certainly explains why struts are used in sculpture.  

But at the end of this article, Cole argues that: 
In these cases, though, the works ... [ including "Truth"]... simply look unfinished. What are we to make of this? It is possible that, after a certain point, the sculptor’s studio no longer commanded the talent to turn out the mesmerizingly virtuoso pieces of Bernini’s youth. ...  Equally likely, though, is that Bernini simply lost interest in blinding his viewers with skill as he had as a youth.

It's possible, I suppose.  

But now that I knew the technical term (struts) I was able to do better searches.  

A search like: 

     [ Bernini struts "Veritas" ] 

now gives me lots of hits, and lots of opinions about what the struts are all about.  

But we've more or less answered the question.  

What's up with the webbing?  

Answer:  It's not webbing, these things are called "struts" and are either: 

 (a) interstitial material left in place to protect the fragile parts of of the statue (typically, delicate parts like fingers, leaves, or thin vines), 

or... 

(b) material that's left in place as a commentary on the material (marble) that's being used, and is intentionally there as a kind of reminder that yes, this is stone, not god-like flesh.  

Personally, given the fit and finish of Bernini's work (both before and after "La Veritas"), I find the second explanation a bit hard to swallow.  I suspect that the work just wasn't done yet, and he wanted to leave some structural support in place until he could finish the figure of Time and get it into place.  



Search lesson:  Big lesson #1:  Finding the right term to describe what you're looking for can sometimes open up everything you want to find.  In this case, learning the word "struts" changed everything.  Basically, every search after that point became fairly targeted and worthwhile.  

The problem is (as we've seen before) that some terms are the key to search in a domain, especially a domain with which you're not intimately familiar.  Typically, those domains are things like medicine, finance, or other highly technical realms.  But sculpture is another one of those domains.  The word "struts" makes perfect sense, but it never would have occurred to me to use it in this context.  

This is a great example of the basic search skill "discovering the key term"  for your domain-specific search.  

A "key term" is the word(s) that lets you have very targeted searches within a topic domain.  These key terms are most easily discovered by reading around in the hits you DO get with your early searches.  Hint:  As you read, be sensitive to the use of words that you don't recognize, or words you do recognize that are being used in interesting and non-standard ways.  

As I said, I got lucky with this search, finding the word "struts" in the Cole article about Bernini.  But even if that article hadn't been about Bernini, learning the key term "struts" would have let me find other articles that would solve the puzzle.  



Postscript:  First off, I have to say that letting the Challenge run for an extra day is a GREAT idea.  The quality of the conversation in the comments is even better than before (when, I assume, people were rushed).  And so many interesting things pop up!   I need to comment on a few of them here.  

The Benini sketch of the planned statue:  This was in a site that many people found (http://bernini2013.org/truth-unveiled-by-time/) that collects a good deal of info about Bernini and his stautes.  In particular, it has the only published version of Bernini's sketch for the statue: 

Sketch by Bernini of planned statue. Source: ArtStor. 

It's a little obscure, but if you stare at it long enough, it seems that the female figure of Truth is on the left of this sketch, with the older male figure of Time lifting off the veil with his right hand.  

This suggests that the statue we see now really IS just a fragment of the entire group.  If so, then it makes sense to leave structural supports in place until the assembly is finally put together.  



Adobe 3D printing--Auto-Struts!  Fred pointed out the happy concurrence of Adobe's announcement about automatically adding in struts when doing 3D printing design.  Honestly, I hadn't planned it, but it's a great coincidence!  




Bernini video:  An interesting hour-long documentary about Bernini giving a psychological backstory of the man, his history, and details of his life. 




Finally, Berlusconi...   

While doing my searches on this topic, I ran across a story so improbable, and yet so true and comical that I have to share it with you. 

Apparently the great 18th century Italian artist Giovanni Battista Tiepolo also made a painting of "Truth Unveiled by Time" around 1743.   

And, apparently, the controversial Italian Prime Minister (of the time) Silvio Berlusconi liked it so much that he had a digital print made of the Tiepolo painting, and then hung it on the wall in his press room at the Palazzo Chigi.  This is all fine, it's his prerogative as head of state to decorate with great Italian art.  

But then, in a move so colossally ironic as to defy belief, he had the painting modified to cover up the nude form of Truth.  

  
That's right.  Even though the point of the painting is to show how Truth is revealed by the passage of time, Berlusconi's office had the painting literally covered up to avoid offending sensitivities.  (Really?  In Italy, where nudes are on every street corner?)  

Mind you, this is a politician who has had some issues with telling the truth in the past, so the irony is hip-deep here.  

Thursday, January 16, 2014

The value of looking up stuff in other languages in Wikipedia

As noted, I'll write up the answer to this week's Search Challenge tomorrow (Friday, 1/17/13).  In the meantime, here's something I've been meaning to write up for a while.  Hope you find this interesting as well.  


________________________________________

You might have been using Wikipedia for a while, and not noticed that there are entire other worlds of information there on the page for you to examine.  Take a look at the left side of this Wikipedia entry about cats... do you see the column over on the left labelled "Languages"?  



Wikipedia comes in 287 languages (and more are being added).  Those links on the left are to the equivalent article in another language.  

What you might not realize is that articles are NOT THE SAME in all of the world's different languages.  Even fairly straight-forward articles, like this one on "cats," can be very different, and well worth looking at for comparison purposes.  

Here, for example, are the outlines of the cat-article in English (on the left) and the Spanish Wikipedia article (on the right, in translation).  Note how very different they are.  

Wikipedia articles on "cat" -- EN version on the left, Spanish version on the right. 
For some reason, the Spanish authors of the "cat" entry go into MUCH greater detail about cat diseases (section 9.1 - 9.13) than the English authors (section 7.1).  The Spanish language edition covers, for example, the effects of second-hand tobacco smoke on the rate of oral cancers among cats.  (Bottom line:  second-hand smoke is bad for your pet cat as well.)  

Bear in mind that the topic of "cat" is fairly non-controversial.  When you compare more culturally, historically, or politically loaded topics, the differences become even greater.  

Here, for example is a comparison of the English and Italian versions of the Wikipedia articles about "Leonardo da Vinci."  It makes sense that the Italian version would be much more in-depth, but it's also interesting to read the different treatments that each culture makes about his personal life and relationships.  (You can click on the image to see it full size.)  

Notice that just Section 1 on the life of Leonardo in Italian (12K words) is longer than the entire article about Leonardo in English (a mere 8K words).  



These kinds of cross-cultural comparisons are fascinating to make, but also potentially really useful when doing your research.  Frustrated by the lack of depth of the Wikipedia article in your language, try another language, perhaps one that's "closer to home" for the material.  

A tool for comparison 

I just recently ran across a wonderful tool that lets you see Wikipedia articles side-by-side.  

Manypedia.com lets you look up a single topic, and then look at the Wikipedia articles from those languages side-by-side.  If we look up a topic we're interested in, say, the sculptor Bernini, we can see the English and Italian (in translation) versions side-by-side.  


I've added two numbers to the screencap to point out a couple of features. 

(1) is the list of all of the images from the Wikipedia article.  Notice how the list of pictures is VERY different between the two articles.  His great work "The Hermaphrodite" isn't even mentioned in the English version, but shows up prominently in the Italian article. You can spot this immediately by looking at the images summary. 

(2) shows a kind of word cloud (font size indicates word frequency in the article) for the Wikipedia entry.  Again, a quick scan shows real differences between the articles.  "Lorenzo" and "Barberini" are more important in Italian, but "Rome" and "Lorenzo" dominate in the English version. 


Search lessons:  When you're looking up a topic that might "more naturally" fit in another language (such as Leonardo da Vinci, or the life of Gian Lorenzo Bernini), consider ALSO checking out the other languages of Wikipedia for additional perspectives and insights.  Often, you'll find a huge variation in the way in which the topics are discussed, and how they're presented.  (For a really interesting transcultural experience, compare the Wikipedia articles on "conspiracy theory" in multiple languages.  You'll see that not everyone thinks of conspiracies the way the US does!)  

Also, if you're interested in a deeper understanding of this kind of cross-language comparison analysis, I highly recommend this paper from my friends at Northwestern University.  They built a system, Omnipedia, that analyzes the differences in Wikipedia articles across languages.  It is a brilliant idea, and well worth the read.  



Wednesday, January 15, 2014

Wednesday Search Challenge (1/15/14): What's up with her fingers?

A continuation of our Art History theme from last week... 

There are just some people that make you feel like you haven't really accomplished much of anything.  

One such person is Gian Lorenzo Bernini (also spelled Gianlorenzo or Giovanni Lorenzo).  Born in Naples (1598), died in Rome (1680) at age 81, he was truly a Renaissance man.  

Bernini was an Italian painter, sculptor, architect, playwright, stage set designer, and city planner. He was the leading sculptor of his age, working for a succession of popes, and is credited with more-or-less singlehandedly creating the Baroque style of sculpture. 

I learned all this while wandering through Rome late last year.  But it was in the Villa Borghese that I had my art history shock.  This is a museum (formerly a residence of the Borghese family) in a large park--think Central Park in New York, Golden Gate Park in San Francisco, or Bois de Boulogne in Paris... that kind of park.  It has a great art collection (all collected by the Borghese family), and a truly remarkable collection of statuary.  

Truthfully, I've never been much of a sculpture fan.  They're nice, but they never quite impressed me in the way that painting or even drawing did.  I realize that stone is a difficult medium to work in, but the statues always seemed sort of static, just sort of there, part of the landscape. 

Then I walked into the Villa Borghese and saw the work of Bernini up close.  

I was astonished.  

Here's what I mean... this is a master sculptor.  He cuts rock as though it were infinitely malleable.  His details are astoundingly lifelike.  


Here's his statue of "Apollo and Daphne"which captures the moment that Daphne is being transformed by the gods into a laurel tree to escape Apollo's clutches.  


Notice the remarkable details and the fluidity with which the transforming fingers and hair are being changed into tree limbs and leaves. 



This is a sculptor of immense skill and a deep understanding of his material.  He knows how to hew the living marble.  Here's one more example that just floored me.  Notice how his fingers slightly dig into her flesh and make a slight, lifelike ripple in the skin.  It's hard to believe this is solid rock. 



So it was a huge shock for me when just a bit later in the museum I ran across another famous Bernini sculpture that seemed completely at odds with what the master sculptor could do. 


Look at her left hand.  After seeing "Apollo and Daphne," I couldn't believe that there was some stuff in-between her fingers.  (Look carefully between her index finger and 3rd finger on the left hand.)  It wasn't added later (I looked VERY carefully), it's original stone that was left there by the sculptor.  Here's another, slightly different angle on the same hand.  



For a sculptor of Bernini's talent and power, why do this?  

It took me a while to figure out the answer to this, but perhaps you'll have better luck than I did. 

1.  Why is there webbing left between the fingers of the left hand of this Bernini sculpture? What's going on there?  

That's it, just one question, but a real question that came up as I was looking at this wonderful piece in the Villa Borghese.  I spent some time in the museum book shop trying to find the answer, but ultimately found it online after I returned home.  

For this one, let us know HOW you figured this one out!  What search terms did you try, and what was the insight or observation that let you solve the challenge.  

As I mentioned last week, I'll post the answer on Friday. But will ALSO post something on Thursday.  Stay tuned... and... 

Search on! 



Friday, January 10, 2014

Answer: What's missing from the sphinx?

Dan's picture of the Great sphinx of Tanis, currently at the Louvre.
As most people found out, this wasn't as difficult a challenge as it might seem.  The only tricky part was figuring out which sphinx this one is.  My preface said "Here's a picture I took of a sphinx in the Louvre..."  so it's pretty clear that this is a sphinx that will fit into a museum.  A few people wrote in with answers about the Great Sphinx of Giza.  That's a fantastic sphinx, but it's in Egypt, and a bit more than 75 meters (241 feet) long.  

So the simplest way to start this search is probably to figure out which sphinx is in my photo.  A quick Image search query of: 

     [ sphinx Louvre ] 

gives a grid of images, and from there it's short work to figure out that the picture is of the Great Sphinx of Tanis (aka the "Tanis Sphinx").  It's located at in the Egypte pharaonique, room 1: Crypt of the Sphynx. 

Pro tip:  Be careful to always check the name of the sphinx that you're searching for--there are multiple different sphinxes associated with Tanis.  Be sure you're discovering information about the pinkish granite one currently in the Louvre. 

Then, to answer the challenge ("What's missing from the forehead?") the fastest solution was to ask about sphinx foreheads in general: 

     [ sphinx forehead  Egypt ] 

(I added the word Egypt to avoid all of the sphinx moth hits.)  

With this query, you quickly learn that sphinxes typically have a headdress (called nemes, that striped cloth worn on the head in a gentle triangle), and an animal headband called a uraeus.  

A search for: 

     [ ureaus ] 

leads to a bunch of articles about this device--typically a cobra which is a symbol for the goddess Wadjet, one of the earliest Egyptian deities, and a symbol of the sovereign, royal, and divine status of the wearer.  

Interestingly, the uraeus was typically a cobra, but later, at the time of the unification of Egypt, the image of Nekhbet (represented as a white vulture; the symbol of Upper Egypt) joined the image of Wadjet on the uraeus.  

Since this particular sphinx is at the Louvre, I decided to search THEIR website for information.  

    [ grand sphinx site:louvre.fr ] 

Which leads to a pretty authoritative museum description of the sphinx.  From that web page we read, 

"This one was successively inscribed with the names of the pharaohs Ammenemes II (12th Dynasty, 1929-1895 BC), Merneptah (19th Dynasty, 1212-02 BC) and Shoshenq I (22nd Dynasty, 945-24 BC). According to archaeologists, certain details suggest that this sphinx dates to an earlier period - the Old Kingdom (c. 2600 BC)." 
 It was found in 1825 among the ruins of the Temple of Amun at Tanis (the capital of Egypt during the 21st and 22nd dynasties), so it was in the sand for at least 3000 years or so.  

Unfortunately, the record doesn't mention whether or not there was a uraeus on the forehead or not, but given the age of the sphinx, it clearly would NOT have been a double, cobra/vulture uraeus, but just a single cobra.  

There was some discussion in the comments about whether or not there really was a uraeus.  But if you look at these images, it's pretty clear something has gone missing... other than the nose.  


Tanis sphinx. Image from Wikimedia.
Tanis sphinx.  Image link to Louvre.fr

And if you zoom in: 

Zooming in on the Louvre's image

Zooming in on one of Dan's photos of the
Tanis sphinx

It certainly seems as though something--the uraeus, the cobra emblem of divinity and right-to-rule--is missing.  

FWIW, the color of the stone is much closer in the first and last photos (the ones I took) than in the others.  (I don't know why people don't white balance their pictures when shooting.  It's not that hard!)

Search lessons:  First, be sure you're searching for the right sphinx!  If you do a quick orientation check, you'll quickly learn that there are a LOT of sphinxes in the world.  Be sure your searches are for the right one.   

Second, visually checking images is a great strategy--it's easy to scan through a bunch of thumbnails, identify the one you're looking for, then dive in and get the details. 

Lastly, using the site:operator is a great way to get instantly to the original source content.  I used it above to scope out the Louvre site.  Note that I searched in English because I knew that the Louvre supported multiple languages.  (Other museums that aren't quite as well funded might require that you search in their language.  Translate your query before searching.)  

Searching on, like an Egyptian! 



Thursday, January 9, 2014

Thursday comment: What's missing from the sphinx?

As mentioned, this is our first regular week of a Challenge that is posted on Wednesday, but answered on Friday.  

But I thought I'd provide a bit of color commentary inbetween. 

As expected, this wasn't that difficult of a challenge.  I was surprised to find that the query: 

    [ sphinx forehead ] 

worked so well.  That's a surprise because it seems to have come from the language I used in writing up the challenge.  And that gives me a useful observation.  

Sometimes when you're stuck on a problem, it's useful to write it up in an email to a friend.  You know, "Dear Joe, I'm trying to find out what this thing is that's on the forehead of the sphinx in this picture..."  

Not infrequently, just writing-it-out (or, alternatively, talking aloud to a Teddy Bear) will cause the so-called "Teddy Bear Effect" to kick in.  That happens when you just go through the motions of explaining it to someone else.  Often that causes you to realize something about the problem you didn't realize.  

Big revelation:  Every TA knows this.  It's happened to me many times.  Someone comes to me with a problem, something they "just can't figure out."  I ask them:  "Tell me what your problem is."  They start talking through the problem.  And even if I don't know anything about their problem, some large fraction of the time the questioner solves the problem on their own.  

And no infrequently they say "Thanks!" as they walk away. 

That's why writing out a problem, as I did with this challenge, is often a great source of clues.  It doesn't always solve the problem, but it works often enough that you should keep this strategy in the back of your mind as you work through a tough problem.  

Keep searching!  Answers tomorrow. 


Wednesday, January 8, 2014

Wednesday Search Challenge (1/8/14): What's missing from the sphinx?

I just got back from my quick trip to Paris, so I'm slightly jetlagged and not thinking clearly.  But, as I was going through my photos from the trip on the flight back, I noticed something a bit... odd.  As you know, that's usually a clue that I'm going to need to do a bit of searching.  Maybe you can help me out with this one? 

Here's a picture I took of a sphinx in the Louvre.  As I noticed when looking at the photo again, there seems to be something missing.  (And I don't mean just his nose.)  It looks very much to me as though there's something broken off from the top of the forehead.  


Can you figure it out?  Should something have been there?  


Today's search challenge:  

1.  What's missing from the head of the sphinx?  Can you figure out this missing-in-action mystery from a few millennia ago?  

2.  Once you've figured out what's missing, what was the significance of that missing part?  

Search on, Egyptologists!   


Friday, January 3, 2014

Answer: Did everyone like the lights?



The short answer seems to be... surprisingly... oui!  

But before we dive into this, the results of our mini-survey are back.  And it's pretty clear that people prefer having the second day to work on the Challenge.  So I'll shift to this plan for a while, see how it goes.  Challenge on Wednesday, and then maybe commentary on what I'm seeing on Thursday, with the answer on Friday.  Sound good?  

Back to the program. 

This Challenge question just came up in conversation, and without thinking about it too much I thought it might be a good SearchResearch question because (I was thinking) it's in another language / culture, and there's probably no simple, definitive way to answer it.  (I was just betting that Wikipedia wouldn't answer it outright.) 

But I didn't count on the question being ambiguous.  As Ramón first pointed out in the comment stream, there have been lights on the Tower going all the way back to the time it was built.  Those were arc lights (which is a lot like the light generated by an electric welding rig--brilliant, dazzling, too much to look at).

I'd just been thinking about the latest installation.  As you see in the photograph, there are actually two lighting systems on the Eiffel Tower.  There's a rotating beacon that cycles around once every 30 seconds, and then a shimmering set of strobes that fire randomly (those are the little white dots you see on the Tower). You can check out the video below (which I didn't take) to get the effect.  


So I guess my question really breaks down into (a) What did Parisians think of ANY lighting scheme, beginning with the first lighting setup from 1889, when the Tower was completed?  And (b) When the strobes were added to the Eiffel Tower, how did they react to THAT?  

What I did... 

I started very much as Rosemary did: 

     [paris newspaper tour eiffel lights OR lumière ] 

That's when I read the Wikipedia article.  And THAT's when I found out that it's always had lights...  As the Wikipedia article says: "After dark the tower was lit by hundreds of gas lamps and a beacon sending out out three beams of red, white and blue light using two mobile projectors mounted on a circular rail..."  

So what I thought was new, was, in fact, as old as the Tower itself.  That put a very different spin onto the question!  

But it was public reaction that I was interested in.  So I thought I'd search for the time when the strobes started up, and also for public reaction when the regular lights began in 1889.  

So I tried: 

     [ public reaction lighting Eiffel Tower ] 

(I dropped the lumière part because it had been around so long that I figured it would be covered in English.)  

I ended up then thinking that perhaps the FRENCH language version of the Wikipedia page would have something.  And while it gave more background (that's NOT in the English version!) on the history of illumination, there wasn't much controversy mentioned.  

Learned from http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tour_Eiffel (in a Google translation):  

"As early as 1888, even before its completion, fireworks were fired from the second floor, and even now, it is the place of rendezvous for every Parisian French national holiday . 
In 1889, and at first, the lighting of the tower are using 10,000 gaslights , but when the 1900 Universal Exhibition , held in Paris , they make electricity. 
In 1925, André Citroën installed a huge advertising light for its brand, ranging in height. Illuminations by 250,000 bulbs in six colors are nine tables, the latter being the name "Citroën" lettering with a stylized version of Art Deco. It remains in place until 1933 that the town has multiplied by six the tax in 1926. 
In 1937, for the International Exhibition of Applied Arts, André Granet new lighting designs highlighting the lace structure of the tower."


What this told me was that something as pretty as the strobe lighting wasn't likely to cause much of a fuss for the Parisians.  It's been used for fireworks, it's been used as advertising (as Remmij brilliantly found--link to Tower with advertising on it!), it's been through multiple colors, styles, types, and patterns of lights.  Twinkling lights probably aren't going to cause anyone to lose much sleep.  

Still, I thought it would be worth a try to check out some French newspaper archives.  To find a decent list of them, I did a search for: 

     [ newspaper archive list ] 

Yes, I'm under no illusions that Google has ALL the world's news archives (esp. in non-EN-speaking countries). 

Luckily, Wikipedia has an outstanding list of links to online archives.  

From there, I could pick and choose a couple of archives (e.g., Le Temps, or Le Gaulois, both of which predate the Eiffel).  With them, I could do simple searches like 

     [ "Tour Eiffel" lumière ]

(I double quoted it to be sure I didn't get references to just Eiffel, the architect, and the word lumière as the French word for light, which also includes illumination.)  

And you can check out the newspapers from those days (sample search in Le Gaulois).  

As we've talked about before, showing the absence of something is often pretty hard.  But I read through about 100 pages (50 pages from each of these two newspapers), and didn't find any harsh words about the light.  (I did read about how "tablecloths of light fill the fields below the Tower.." and about how such-and-such a worker was injured when a bolt fell several stories and opened up a cut on his wrist during the final stages of construction... but negative press about the illumination?  None.  

I did pretty much the same procedure for the more recent strobes.  Again, nothing.  

In desperation, I asked a couple of Parisian friends--"Do YOU remember anything controversial about the strobes when they were introduced?"  

They both couldn't remember anything except delight when the new lights came online.  

Now, a caution goes here:  I'm not a historian of Paris, but my searches into several online resources (including contemporary French newspapers and writings) don't reveal much, if ANY controversy about the lighting.  The construction of the entire Tower, yes.  But everyone seems to have enjoyed the lighting. Of course, the famous writer Guy de Maupassant often ate lunch in the restaurant at the base of the Eiffel Tower, not because he liked the food, but because it was the only place in Paris he could avoid its otherwise unavoidable profile.  [1] 

Search Lessons:  There are a couple of lessons here...  

First--never assume a question is as simple as your assumptions make it out to be.  I would have SWORN this was a simple question when I asked it.  I'd foolishly assumed that the installation of the blinky strobes was the first time the Eiffel Tower had been illuminated.  When you start a research task... question your assumptions.  

Or, at very least, hold on to them very lightly.  You might have to give them up, and you don't want to waste a lot of time trying to work yourself out of a lot of assumed ratholes! 

Second--Know about the Wikipedia list of newspaper archives.  It's a remarkable resource to draw upon, especially for non English-language research challenges.  

If this was the kind of question I thought I was going to do a lot, I might well create a Custom Search Engine for the task, and seed it with URLs I found there.  



And don't, under any circumstances, do something as foolish as this man, who designed a "coat parachute" and tested it out by leaping from the Eiffel Tower.  It looks like a wing suit, but it isn't a wing suit after all.  It's just slightly slower way to kill yourself.  Check out those assumptions!!!  

From OddstuffMagazine.com 



Search on! 


---- 
References: 

[1] Barthes, Roland. The Eiffel Tower and Other Mythologies. (1997) Tr. Howard, Richard. Berkeley: University of California Press.  





Thursday, January 2, 2014

One more day...

Mes amis, 

Having too much fun in Paris!  Yes this is a real vacation, and if we're not at Notre Dame, we're checking out the Impressionists at Musee d'Orsay, and walking up and down the Seine, munching on croissants, consuming roasted chestnuts, and enjoying the Parisian life. 

I'll answer yesterday's Eiffel Tower challenge tomorrow, after I've caught up on sleep a bit.  
(The other thing I've noticed is that when challenges go on for an extra day, more people get the chance to answer.  Question:  Should Search Challenges always be 2 days long?  That is, ask on Wednesday, let the discussion happen throughout Thursday, and then answer on Friday?  What do you think?)  

Onward!  

Rose window at Notre Dame, Paris
a

Wednesday, January 1, 2014

Wednesday search challenge (1/1/14): Did everyone like the lights?

As fate would have it, I've been in Paris this week.  Not working (really!), but just on vacation, enjoying the city.  

Naturally, last night I had to watch the Eiffel Tower turn all sparkly and put on its light show at midnight.  So I walked down to the Place de la Concorde and stood around with about a million other folks and enjoyed the cool night air, the show on the tower, and the show of all the revelers on the city streets.  

Midnight at the Place de la Concorde

Naturally, this made me think about a search challenge.  Not a hard one in particular, but one that you can pursue to whatever depth you'd like.  

As you probably know, the Eiffel Tower was an object of some, shall we say skepticism when it was built.  As one writer put it:  
"... imagine for a moment a giddy, ridiculous tower dominating Paris like a gigantic black smokestack, crushing under its barbaric bulk Notre Dame, the Tour Saint-Jacques, the Louvre, the Dome of les Invalides, the Arc de Triomphe, all of our humiliated monuments will disappear in this ghastly dream. And for twenty years…we shall see stretching like a blot of ink the hateful shadow of the hateful column of bolted sheet metal"
Of course, over the years it has become one of the most beloved symbols of Paris. 

And then I wondered--If the Parisans were that hard on the Tower when it was first built, what did they think of the lights when they were first installed? 

Today's question (again, not hard, but go as deep as you like...) 

1. Did Parisians like the new light show when they were first installed?  Or did they think of them as wildly excessive and somewhat crass?  

The easy solution here is to look for the English language resources.  But a more motivated searcher might look for original sources (say, French or Parisian newspapers of the time) and get a "sense of the time" from the people in the city.  

Bonne Année! 

Search on!