A couple of weeks ago...
I posted a few fishy pictures with the cryptic question "Have any ideas where these are, or where I am?"
The SearchResearchers rose to the Challenge and were able to identify my location pretty well!
Regular Reader Chris wrote in that:
While Remmij and Ramón both identified the fish and the geography those fish cover. They also figured it out as Fiji, but Remmij went on to check species co-occurence by trying to figure out what kind of anemone that particular anemone-fish was living with.
That's a great strategy, and if I'd thought about it, I would have included a better picture of the anemone (which would have helped identify it).
Alas, this particular anemonefish, Clark's Anemonefish (Amphiprion clarkii) happens to be pretty undiscriminating: "Clark's anemonefish is the least host specific anemonefish, living in association with all ten species of sea anemones that host anemonefish..."
The SearchResearchers are superb. Excellent job.
But here's what I would have done: I would have saved all of the images to my desktop and noticed that they look like this:
Truthfully, I'd forgotten that I'd left all of the filenames on the images, so that when you saved them, you'd see all of the identifying information.
You correctly identified the Anthius in pic #1, and the Clark's anemonefish in #2. The anemonefish in #3 is a "Fiji anemonefish" (Amphiprion barberi), although in this case the color is a bit off, so it's difficult to tell.
The "fusiliers on parade" are, in fact, Blue and Yellow Fusiliers (Caesio teres).
And, when you look at all of these different fish geographical range, it's pretty much narrowed down to Fiji.
Remmij is correct--we were on the island of Taveuni, which is a very well-known dive location, home to the Somosomo Strait, and one of the world's best locations to see soft corals, which I didn't include in this set of images--I thought it would be too much of a give-away!
But here's a bit of video from our dives that gives a great sense of what it was like. Listen carefully--you'll hear humpback whales singing in the background!
Great job, SearchResearchers!
Bula!
I posted a few fishy pictures with the cryptic question "Have any ideas where these are, or where I am?"
The SearchResearchers rose to the Challenge and were able to identify my location pretty well!
Regular Reader Chris wrote in that:
Picture 1 looks like some sort of Serranid- I'm guessing an Anthias which are widespread in the South Pacific, but it doesn't look like the endemic species for Fiji, but comparing google image searches for [anthias fiji] and [antihas vanuatu] tends to lean towards Fiji as the location
Picture 2 is a Clown fish- once again could be anywhere in South Pacific- The yellow colour is different to what I normally see in Australia
Picture 3 I don't recognise- maybe a clown fish again - I'm guessing this is the one that identifies the island group
Picture 4 is a yellow tail fusilier - very common in both Vanuatu and Fiji
While Remmij and Ramón both identified the fish and the geography those fish cover. They also figured it out as Fiji, but Remmij went on to check species co-occurence by trying to figure out what kind of anemone that particular anemone-fish was living with.
That's a great strategy, and if I'd thought about it, I would have included a better picture of the anemone (which would have helped identify it).
Alas, this particular anemonefish, Clark's Anemonefish (Amphiprion clarkii) happens to be pretty undiscriminating: "Clark's anemonefish is the least host specific anemonefish, living in association with all ten species of sea anemones that host anemonefish..."
The SearchResearchers are superb. Excellent job.
But here's what I would have done: I would have saved all of the images to my desktop and noticed that they look like this:
Truthfully, I'd forgotten that I'd left all of the filenames on the images, so that when you saved them, you'd see all of the identifying information.
You correctly identified the Anthius in pic #1, and the Clark's anemonefish in #2. The anemonefish in #3 is a "Fiji anemonefish" (Amphiprion barberi), although in this case the color is a bit off, so it's difficult to tell.
The "fusiliers on parade" are, in fact, Blue and Yellow Fusiliers (Caesio teres).
And, when you look at all of these different fish geographical range, it's pretty much narrowed down to Fiji.
Remmij is correct--we were on the island of Taveuni, which is a very well-known dive location, home to the Somosomo Strait, and one of the world's best locations to see soft corals, which I didn't include in this set of images--I thought it would be too much of a give-away!
But here's a bit of video from our dives that gives a great sense of what it was like. Listen carefully--you'll hear humpback whales singing in the background!
Great job, SearchResearchers!
Bula!
missed the file names - good reminder to check.
ReplyDelete#3 - Amphiprion barberi (orange, broad white vertical body stripes, no longitudinal stripe) vs Amphiprion perideraion…
hard to dispute ground/creator truth, but I was keying off the width of the white stripes as well as the white stripe that ran down the spine longitudinally - pinkish color seemed pretty close?
Amphiprion perideraion also known as the pink skunk clownfish or pink anemonefish, is a species of anemonefish from the skunk complex
Pink Anemonefish
Skunk clownfishes in anemone - in the host anemone Heteractis magnifica
close to your photo's pose
fwiw -
Vanuatu
Ring of Fire
I missed the file names too, Remmij in both SRS Challenges.
DeleteA few minutes ago, read the news and found: The ancient condiment that came back from the dead
It was once thought that the ancient Roman fish sauce garum was lost to history – but today, chefs and archaeologists are bringing it back to modern menus. That we Searched almost 5 years ago
Search search challenge (12/12/12): What's the connection?
More about fishes, Ocean and beautiful sites. Revillagigedo video https://youtu.be/Ox3aCM6hoHk
DeleteI wonder if Dr. Russell have been snorkeling there and how many species Remmij and Dr. Russell identify in the video
The video posted yesterday it is not available in other countries, so here is another link. Hope this works. Revillagigedo-islands video and more
DeleteAnd another video from the expedition DeepSee Submersible in Action: Nat Geo Pristine Seas Expedition to Socorro
I'm in the wrong country… will have to stay in space.
DeleteLas Islas de Revillagigedo | Mares Mexicanos | Nat Geo
Revillagigedo
Storm Ophelia, Ireland
ireland hurricane twit t e rrrrr
bbc
did find these to get a sense –
from 2015
1:11 in impressive…
space clowns over the NoCal fires…
ReplyDeleteThe visibility is not great, recent weather event? Terribly jealous as I haven't been allowed to dive for 31 years! Nice work with the humpback song- alas, I've never made it to Fiji but done a lot of snorkelling in Vanuatu, so the fish all seemed familiar- not sure that they are only endemic to Fiji, but maybe the anemone are?? I forgot to add that I used the Australian Museum website as my starting point for identification https://australianmuseum.net.au/search-fish-images-by-keyword - an amazing resource for divers collated by an equally enthusiastic ichthyologist.
ReplyDeleteon twitter
Deletekraken
@austmus
1 William Street
Dan appears to be busy instructing…
Journalism Interactive 2017 Program
& @ NatGeo in D.C.:
October 23, 2017 "Advanced Search Skills" National Geographic Society, Washington, DC (invitation only)
future dive?
DeleteBVI Art Reef
that's a good example, neat site
ReplyDelete