Thursday, August 11, 2016

More than you might want to know about "barren zones" around bushes (update with additional images)

As I mentioned last week, 

I went back up to the place where I took some of those original pics of the plant-free zone around chaparral bushes.  This place is Black Mountain (37.319795, -122.163153), a mixed oak woodland, chaparral, and grassland.

Overview of barren zone site.  Black Mountain.  Image from Google Maps.

I had speculated that small bushes couldn't provide enough cover to let small critters live within (and therefore wouldn't have a barren zone around them).

I went up there to check.  Here are a few images from my walk up there...

I went to this brush complex (#1 in the map below; just off the trail), and took the closeup photo pointing my camera in the direction of the arrow (and standing at the tip of the red arrow at 37.318673, -122.157772).  This is around 56 square meters in size, and just about the smallest brush complex I could find with a clear barren zone. 

Brush complex #1 from the air

You can see the barren zone here in the closeup, while in the satellite photo, it's only visible on the far side of the brush complex. What's interesting here is that the barren zone is hidden in shadows (in the satellite image), but obviously visible at the time of day when I took this picture.  

Closeup of Brush complex #1


Here's another image, taken just off another giant brush complex not far away.  Look carefully at the image below, you can see this one is large enough to have trees (the dark spots) growing in the center.  (This is brush complex #2 in the map below.)

Brush complex #2 (a large complex around 4 hectares in area).

As you can see, I laid out a tape measure so you can see the width of the barren zone (just over 39" or 1m).  This zone is so wide that it's also used as a deer trail (lots of hoofprints making a clear deer path here).  For some of these barren zones, it seems there's more than just herbivory by small mammals going on, at least at the larger brush complexes.


This closeup was taken on the west side of the large brush complex.  Given the mature size of the brush (a mix of coyote brush chamise and even a few small oak trees in the middle), I'm not surprised that this brush complex shelters more than just rabbits and ground squirrels.  
The above closeup was taken here, on the west side of brush complex #2




And another, this time, a smaller complex. Brush complex #3, shown below, is around 81 square meters.



Here you can see that the barren zone is a little smaller than those of other complexes. This leads me to wonder if the width of the barren zone is a function of the area of the brush complex.    


After looking at a LOT of brush complexes, I noticed that at some point, the brush complex gets too small to even shelter small mammals, and as a consequence, they do NOT have any barren zones.  (See image below.)  

A small coyote bush with no barren zone (too small). Brush complex #5. 

Here's an interactive map of the places I took these images.  (You can zoom in/out and click on a brush complex outline to see the area estimation.)  

Interactive Map of five Brush Complexes. Click on each to see the size of the complex. (The blue drop pin shows the location of complex #1.)  


Summary

My wanderings around on Black Mountain aren't really a substitute for a proper field study.  To do proper science, I'd have to do a lot of field measurements and careful tabulation of my findings.  

But I have to say that I looked at a LOT of brush complexes up there (probably 100 or so), and in NO case did I find a barren zone around a brush complex that was smaller than 10 square meters.  If the allelopathy hypothesis were correct, then you'd expect to see a tiny barren zone... but not nothing. 

On the other hand,  I did notice a few large brush complexes that didn't have a barren zone--but in all cases, they were on fairly steep slopes.  I hadn't anticipated that, but it fits in with the small mammal herbivory effect causing the barren zones.  Squirrels don't seem to mind a slope, but I suspect that rabbits don't want to be grazing downslope of a brush complex if a predator comes along.  Running uphill isn't a great defensive strategy.  

The big surprise was that so much of this initial work can be done through satellite photos.  The barren zones (at least of the larger brush complexes) is quite visible on Google Maps or Google Earth.  Of course, you still need to go out into the field and validate, but I'm constantly impressed by how much early phase science can be done remotely.  

As always, 

Search on!  


Wednesday, August 10, 2016

SearchResearch Challenge (8/10/16): Pineapples and radomes in Hawaiʻi?


Technically, I'm on vacation... 

... but that just means I'm in an interesting location with even MORE questions that keep popping up!  

This week I'm on Oahu, the "main" island in the Hawaiian archipelago.  It's the island where Honolulu (the capital) is located, along with most of the ukuleles, dancers, and novelty items for sale. 

But I'm up on the North Shore for vacation--the home of the Banzai Pipeline, Jack Johnson, Waimea Bay, and large open areas of forested mountains, and open shorelines.  

As I've been traveling around up here, I've noticed a couple of things that I hope the SRS Regulars can help out with.  Here's what's puzzling me this week... 

1. Driving to the North Shore we passed through fields of pineapples.  Historically, pineapples (and sugar cane) have been the mainstays of Hawaiian agricultural exports.  But the pineapple fields seem... small to me.  How many acres of pineapple are planted on Oahu these days? (This might sound similar to last week's Challenge, but no fancy programming needed...)  
2.  I know there are many different kinds of pineapples, but which variety is the most commonly planted on Oahu?  (Here's my closeup photo of a pineapple from central Oahu. Yeah, it's pretty prickly in there--you don't want a job picking pineapples!)  


3.  I drove past this strange collection of what look like radomes peeking out over the hilltops.  Can you figure out what's going on here?  (This is at 21.685451, -158.009686) 


4.  (Extra credit)  This radome site is clearly very modern, but this isn't the first radar installation near this location.  There was  a historically very famous site near here.  Can you figure out what that radar site was and why it's so famous? 

As always, tell us how you figured them out.  

I'll be sending aloha your way this week.  

Search on! 


Monday, August 8, 2016

Answer: How many center-pivot irrigation systems do you see?

How DO you count so many center-pivot systems?

We started last week's Challenge with two satellite images.  The first is from a large center-pivot farm at 29.9653127, 38.3618227 in the northern part of Saudi Arabia.   

Center pivot fields in Saudi Arabia at 29.9653127, 38.3618227 (P/C Google Earth)


And another image from the middle of the US that also has a lot of center-pivot systems: 


Center pivot fields in the US at 37.4359878,-101.6097197 (P/C Google Earth)

(Remember that you can click on those images to get the full-resolution image, for close-up viewing or downloading.)    

Our Challenges for this week are:  

1.  (Easy) What's the most obvious difference between the US and the Saudi center-pivot irrigation systems?  (There are a lot of them.  Can you list one or two? How did you figure it out?)   

There are LOTS of differences, but let's use Google Earth to do some quick measures.  Just how big are these things? 

Notice that almost all of the center-pivot systems in Saudi Arabia are almost exactly the same size.  What IS that size?  

By jumping to that location in Google Earth and using the measurement tool, we see that they're exactly 1 kilometer across.   


 
Interestingly, in the US, the circles come in two sizes, large and small.  Want to guess what their diameters are? 



The smaller one is half the diameter of the larger one, which is why you often see things like this: 


We can go on in this vein, but before we tackle the harder problem, let's look at where both of these center-pivot fields are located:  



Both are in fairly flat (easier to build the irrigation systems) and dry (so they really need irrigation) locations.  Both happen to be near borders with other states (or countries), and both are near cities and decent transportation systems. 

(And, as noted by our regular SRS readers, both places rely on aquifers that are not being replaced; hence both locations are in danger of creating their own localized droughts.)  



2.  (Hard)  How many center-pivot irrigation fields can you count in both of the images shown here?  Both images were taken from an altitude of 40 miles--but which location has more of the circular-disk-shaped fields?  (You should count but little and big fields.)  
I pondered this Challenge for a while before realizing that counting by hand is one solution. And you could do that.  But I was thinking about what might be a more general solution... suppose we wanted to count all of the center-pivot irrigation systems in all of Kansas or all of Saudi Arabia?  Counting by hand would be a bit tedious and error prone.  

What would Dan do?  I'd search for a tool to help out.  

I did the obvious searches for tools that would search for circles in images, until finally I did this search: 

     [ tools detecting circles in image ]  

This was what I needed...  Here's what I found: 



I started reading the first link here about how to detect circles in images by using the Matlab system.  
Background:  Matlab is a system that lets you do math, graphics, image analysis, and programming all in one package.  It's a product of Mathworks and can be incredibly handy when you have a task that requires you doing some kinds of analysis.  I have no affiliation with them--this just happened to be the tool that I found.

As luck would have it, Matlab has a fantastic "try it out for 30 days" evaluation mode. (THANKS, Mathworks! This is awesome!)  I definitely wanted to test it out, so I downloaded the package onto my Mac laptop and started following the directions in the article. 

The good news is that it works exactly as advertised.  (This isn't always true for articles and systems you read about on the web. It's to their credit that the stuff actually works as advertised.)  

Based on the article, I was able to copy their code and adapt it to our purposes.  

This is what Matlab looks like in operation.  This is just after I'd run my code (in the center window) and it's telling me the number of circles it found in the image.  


Here's the way it works:  You write a few lines of code (see below), and run it over an image, in our case, the pictures of the Saudi and the US irrigation locations.  The code looks at the image and tries to find as many circles in the image as possible.  

Here's the code I used (adapted from the article above): 

% read in center-pivot image 
US-image = imread('CPI-US.jpg');
 
% make the image into a "figure" so we can compute on it 
figure
 
% show images as a window 
imshow(US-image)
 
% find small circles with sensitivity = 0.96
[centers, radii] = imfindcircles(US-image,[6 9],
 'ObjectPolarity','dark', 'Sensitivity', 0.96) 
% show the circles on the window
h = viscircles(centers,radii); 
% how many circles did this code find? 
length(radii)

 What this code does is: 

1. read in the image file

2. makes the image visible on my display

3. runs the "imfindcircles" function over the image, looking for circles that are between
         6 and 9 pixels wide with a sensitivity factor of 0.96

4. it outputs the center locations AND radii of the circles

5.  it draws the circles on the (visible) image

6.  the length of the radii is the number of circles it found in the image 

The only work I really needed to do was to figure out the size of the circles (in pixels) and then play around with the sensitivity parameter until it found all of the circles that I saw in the image, and didn't hallucinate anything.  

Basically, the 'Sensitivity' value tells the program how much to amplify the difference in the colors in the image.  If the difference between adjacent pixels is small, it will make that more apparent in the image.  It's a bit like turning up the volume on the ability of the program to make distinctions.  

Here are my notes as I was playing with the system.  The number (0.99, etc) is the Sensitivity parameter, and the integer next it is the number of circles it found.  

  0.99 = 3459 (way too many) 
  0.95 = 172 (missing a lot) 
  0.97 = 1029 (too many, missing faint ones; missing large circles) 
  0.96 = 456 (missing some, but pretty close) 

To show you what I mean, here's the circle finder set at 0.99:  


And here it is set at 0.90 (which is way too low--it's missing a lot of circles): 


But at 0.96 it finds most of the small circles (it finds 456, while missing a few), but it also misses ALL of the larger circles.  

So I re-ran it with the "circle size" parameter set to find circles between 10 and 20: 

     [centers, radii] = imfindcircles(c2,[10 20],'ObjectPolarity','dark', 'Sensitivity', 0.92)

Again, I had to play around with the Sensitivity parameter, and found that 0.92 is about right (for larger circles).  If you add the small circles with the large circles, you see 499 circles in the US image.  It looks like this: 


If you look at this image carefully, you'll see it's undercounting by just a bit.  (It misses around 20 small circles and 5 large ones.)  And if you look at the misses, it's often because the circle is barely visible.  Is it a center-pivot irrigation system that is out-of-operation?  

As with many of the Challenges, we have to define our question carefully--and implicitly, what our answer will be as well.  

In this case, we've used a program to find around 500 center-pivot irrigation systems.  With a bit more tuning (and futzing around with the image contrast) we could probably find a few more--but this was about 30 minutes of work on my part, and the accuracy is pretty good.  

This becomes ever more evident when you look at the center-pivot farms in Saudi Arabia.  

Once more I had to tune the Sensitivity parameter for this image (setting it to 0.99) and found the following:  


We're missing a few (especially at the bottom--fields that are out of commission?), and we seem to be hallucinating a few on the left.  Here, the overcount is close to the undercount, so we'll accept the number of circles found as being close to the actual number--in this case, the program found 1699 circles.  

Search Lessons


1.  Use the tools at hand to get a quick overview.  In our case, using Google Earth's ruler tool let us find that the center-pivot systems in Saudi Arabia are metric.  That seems obvious in retrospect, but it leaps out at you when you compare it with US fields.  

.... but don't stop with the simple tools... 

2. Learn what tools are available to you... even more sophisticated ones.  In this week, we see that some programming is incredibly handy to know.  In truth, you didn't need to know much (other than copy-and-paste), but just have an inclination to tinker with the code to figure out what would work.  

In general, learning to code is a great thing to do, if only because you'll now know how to create your own tools (or at least, you'll know how to adapt the tools that are already out there for you).  

In this case I happened to know that "circle finders" were a thing--a tool I could probably use to help solve this problem.  (Did you know this?)  

 One obvious one in this category might be something to convert scanned text (e.g., text captured in a picture) into searchable text.  You can imagine when such a thing would be handy.  

What other kinds of tools are out there like this? 

The more you know, the more robust your SearchResearch skills.  

Search on! 


Thursday, August 4, 2016

SearchResearch Challenge (8/4/16): How many center-pivot irrigation systems do you see?


One of the most striking things about flying... 

... is looking down and seeing giant fields of circles on the Earth below.  If you've ever seen these, you might have wondered what they are.  They are NOT UFO landing sites, but are just fields that are being served by center-pivot irrigation systems.  Here's an example from Saudi Arabia (at 29.9653127, 38.3618227), where you can see that they are literally making the desert bloom (or at least turn a impressively dark shade of green.


Center pivot fields in Saudi Arabia at 29.9653127, 38.3618227 (P/C Google Earth)


When you're on the ground, there's a long, linear contraption that rotates about a central pivot hub, spraying water as it moves in a giant circle.  



which is driven from the center pivot that sends water down the pipeline.  


Center pivot hub, feeding irrigation water down the line.  

As you can see, these are pretty impressive systems.

Recently, as I was flying over the middle of America, I was wondering how the center-pivot systems in the US differ from other countries such as the Saudi system shown above in the first image. 

Here's an image from the middle of the US that has a lot of center-pivot systems: 


Center pivot fields in the US at 37.4359878,-101.6097197 (P/C Google Earth)

Obviously the soil is very different here. But what else is different here?  My curiosity leads to today's two SearchResearch Challenges:  


1.  (Easy) What's the most obvious difference between the US and the Saudi center-pivot irrigation systems?  (There are a lot of them.  Can you list one or two? How did you figure it out?)   
2.  (Hard)  How many center-pivot irrigation fields can you count in both of the images shown here?  Both images were taken from an altitude of 40 miles--but which location has more of the circular-disk-shaped fields?  (You should count but little and big fields.)  

The second question is a bit tricky.  Here are a couple of hints... 

A.  There are better ways than counting by hand.  Can you think what they might be? 

B.  I don't know of any obvious way to use Google to directly answer this Challenge.  I used Google in the process of solving it, but it was somewhat indirect. 

C.  Before you spend a lot of time trying random things, think carefully:  What would be a good way to approach a Challenge like this?  What would be the best approach?  (You should think to yourself:  What would Dan do??)  


As always, be sure to tell us HOW you solved this Challenge.  Tell us what steps you went through to solve this.  (For calibration, it took me about 10 minutes to find a method, and then about 2 hours to figure out how to use the method to come up with an answer.  

Search on!  


Wednesday, August 3, 2016

Answer: Mind the gap!


Things are often not what they seem...  
 


Recall this week's Challenge:  We're trying to understand what's causing this gap around the plants up in the chaparral on Black Mountain (in the Santa Cruz range).  


1.  What causes the odd, plant-free gap around the plants in these photos?  



What struck me about each of these pictures is that there's a noticable gap between the green plant and the grassland next to it.  Oddly, this doesn't happen ALL the time, but it does happen a lot.  


The plants here are chamise (Adenostoma fasciculatum), but I'm pretty sure I saw gaps like this around coyote brush (Baccharis pilularis) in the same area.  

What's going on here? 

I began my search with: 

     [ plant free zone OR area near chamise OR "coyote brush" ] 

but these results weren't especially good.  I learned a lot about how to create "plant free zones" around houses, especially those that are built in chaparral or near fire-prone plants like chamise.  I also learned a great deal about chamise, such as: 
"Under natural conditions, dormant seeds accumulate in the soil until stimulated by fire to germinate [66,126].  Chamise seeds are unpalatable and seedbanks apparently are not subject to heavy predation [111]. Consequently, chamise seed densities increase over time [133].  Seed density in the seedbank beneath 9-year-old stands was estimated at 2,000 seeds per square meter while in 85-year-old stands, seed density was approximately 21,000 seeds per square meter [132]."  (From the Federal Fire Effects Information system, which includes descriptions of plants like chamise.)

Reading through these articles was interesting, but not especially useful.  (Or so I thought.  See below...)  

I modified my query to focus in on just chamise: 

     [ plants not grow near chamise ] 

and I had a bunch of new, additional results about chamise.  But one result struck my eye, a PDF from the Santa Cruz County Parks Department that said (in the snippet) "...chamise uses allelopathy, altering the soil as it drops leaves..."  This sounded as though it MIGHT be relevant, so I clicked through to the landing page and found these lines that sounds like our solution... 
"Some plants engage in chemical warfare, or allelopathy. Chamise accumulates toxic, water-soluble compounds as a result of normal metabolic processes. Fog drip and rain carry these toxins to the soil, where they inhibit the growth of competing plants."
Now this sounds like the right mechanism--this very well might cause a zone around the chamise that would be pretty barren.  However, this paragraph uses a word that's new to me: "allelopathy," so...   

I looked it up: "allelopathy" means"the chemical inhibition of one plant (or other organism) by another, due to the release into the environment of substances acting as germination or growth inhibitors."   This very well could be exactly what's happening to cause the plant free zone around the bushes.  Broccoli and black walnut, for instance, both exude substances that kill (or prevent from growing) plants living nearby.  So, maybe we've found the answer.

And now that I know this word, I remembered seeing it before--in the first set of results!  Now I know what that word means, and I see in retrospect that my first hint was actually in the first search I did, if only I'd known.

This is now officially interesting, so I dug a little deeper into the "allelopathy" vein.  

I thought what I'd do is to search for "allelopathy" for chamise, with the obvious query:   

     [ allelopathy chamise ] 

Not only did I find a lot of new results, but I found myself in the middle of a scientific battle of explanations!! 

Look at the results page here: 

  
As I read the first result, I was astonished:  this link gives you an idea about what's going on.  In that article, published in 2004 (in the oldest botanical publication in the US) the author calls into question the idea that chamise is allelopathic.  So I did a bit of searching and reading of these pages.  Here's what I found:  

On the "allelopathy side" are publications that argue that chamise IS allelopathic, and causes the plant-free zone around chamise: 

Keeley, J. E., Morton, B. A., Pedrosa, A., & Trotter, P. (1985). "Role of allelopathy, heat and charred wood in the germination of chaparral herbs and suffrutescents"  The Journal of Ecology, 445-458. 
McPherson, J. K., & Muller, C. H. (1969). "Allelopathic effects of Adenostoma fasciculatum, "chamise", in the California chaparral"  Ecological Monographs, 39(2), 177-198. 
Muller, C. H. 1953. "The association of desert annuals with shrubs" Am. J. Botany 40: 53-60. 
Muller, Cornelius H., Hanawalt, R. B., McPherson, J. K. "Allelopathic Control of Herb Growth in the Fire Cycle of California Chaparral" Bulletin of the Torrey Botanical Club 95(3)  (May - Jun., 1968),  225-231 

Notice that these publications are all a few years old.  Science marches on.  We should look for more recent work.  

There are a few more recent publications that argue this is all wrong, that allelopathy isn't really what's going on here (at least for chamise):
Halsey, Richard W. "In search of allelopathy: an eco-historical view of the investigation of chemical inhibition in California coastal sage scrub and chamise chaparral." Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society (2004): 343-367.   
Weidenhamer, Jeffrey D. "Distinguishing resource competition and chemical interference: overcoming the methodological impasse." Agronomy Journal 88.6 (1996): 866-875.
After reading a bunch of these papers, it becomes clear that the idea that chamise is allelopathic originated in Muller's original paper from 1953.  But that since then, the idea that chamise actively emits chemicals (or, more likely, that the chemicals are leached off in rainwater over the plant) has been called into question.  

There's no doubt that some plants do emit compounds that suppress nearby growth, the question being debated here is whether or not chamise is one of them or not.  The articles are fairly detailed, with long sections describing how to test one idea or the other. Fascinating reading, if you're into details of methodology (which I actually quite enjoyed, but maybe that's just me), but I'll just summarize it by saying these folks are still trying to figure it out.  However... 

A very nice summary of this entire debate is contained in a relatively recent book, Perspectives on plant competition (2012) by James Grace and David Tilman.  They conclude that allelopathy by chamise and other chaparral plants is "...overrated... if not altogether fictitious..." (p 146).  

Why this might matter is because some botanists are trying to figure out ways to harness plants natural allelopathic capability to do weed suppression in fields, and perhaps farm without using any weedkiller sprays on the crops.  In essence, if chamise IS allelopathic, might it be possible to breed (or genetically engineer) a food plant that needs no weedkiller, but can grow just fine on its own?  

HOWEVER.. while reading Perspectives on plant competition, I looked up each of the citations of Muller's work, and in particular each reference in the text about allelopathy.  In the process, I found this remarkable phrase on page 145.  

"... experimental evidence supporting an alternative explanation for the bare zones around chaparral shrubs.  Batholomew (1970) demonstrated that halos around some shrubs in the soft chaparral might be maintained by herbivory from animals inhabiting the shrubs. Successive attempts to test the relative importance of allelopathy versus herbivory in both the development and the maintenance of bare zones showed that chemical inhibition occurred in some species, but not in others and that the herbivory of unexclosed seedlings could be an intense as 100% (Halligan, 1973, 1975, 1976; Christiensen and Muller, 1975)." 
I know that's dense prose, but WOW!  If you decode this text, they're saying that animals are eating the small plants around the shrubs.  (That's what "herbivory" means--animals eating plants.  "Unexclosed" means there's no animal-excluding fence around the small plants just outside of the shrub.)  And not just some of the plants, but up to 100% of them!  

Looking up the Bartholmew reference (Bartholomew, B (1970), "Bare zone between California shrub and grassland communities: the role of animals"  Science 170, 1210-1212), we find that 

"...Previous studies have emphasized the role of volatile inhibitors of plant growth in producing this bare zone. However, there is a concentration of feeding activity by rodents, rabbits, and birds in this zone; if this activity is prevented by means of wire-mesh exclosures, annuals grow in the bare zone. Thus, animal activity is sufficient to produce the bare zone."  

Among other things, we now have a technical term for this region around the outside of chamise and coyote brush:  bare zone.  My next query was: 

     [ "bare zone" chaparral shrub ] 

and--voila!-- we have a lot of articles on the bare zone around chaparral plants, just as we're seeing in the photos.  The consensus of opinion now seems to be that the bare zone is caused by animals that are foraging near the clusters of chaparral shrubs. (Bartholomew, 1970; Halligan, 1974; Bradford 1976; Barbour et al., 2000, etc)  

In this long list of articles, there's a wonderful (and very readable) one from Bay Nature magazine entitled "A Landscape Shaped by Fear on Mount Diablo."  In it, the author writes: 

Muller’s work was later challenged by researchers who argued that his work glossed over the role of hungry seed and plant eaters. “In California, the chaparral and coastal sage shrubs form excellent cover for rodents, rabbits, and birds,” Stanford graduate student Bruce Bartholomew wrote in a seminal 1970 paper. 
These small animals leave the shelter of chaparral in search of food. But they don’t go far, lest they themselves become a meal for hawks, bobcats, mountain lions, coyotes and other predators. That’s why the bare zone is also called the “scurry zone.” 
Where Bartholomew set up cages excluding small animals, the bare zone largely disappeared. That and followup experiments led to the view held by many field biologists today, that wary little animals play a huge role in keeping chaparral-grassland borders free of vegetation. In their view, the bare zone is not so much a strip of dirt poisoned by plant chemicals, it’s a landscape shaped by fear.


The article is well worth a read.  In it, you meet UC Berkeley botanist Lindsey Hendricks-Franco and a great picture of the exclosures she's set up to test her hypothesis about small animal herbivory at the margins of burned zones in the chaparral causes bare zones there.  

Of course, not being satisfied with what I'd read, I decided to go back out to my local chaparral and do a few of my own observations.  Here are two photos that are pretty suggestive of what's going on:  

A bare zone beside coyote bush (which nobody believes has any allelopathic effects on nearby plants). 
 Above you see a bare zone next to a large stand of coyote bush.  So far as I know, there hasn't been any report of allelopathy for coyote bush.  If that's true, what's causing the bare zone next to it?  Probably the small animals that live within.  Meanwhile, just down the trail I saw this:  

Grass growing immediately next to a small patch of chamise.

And here you see a bunch of grass growing right next to a small patch of chamise.  If it was truly allelopathic, why would the grass be growing there?  

Note that the stand of chamise is pretty small.  I noticed that small patches of chamise  OR coyote bush don't have bare zones, while large patches of chamise OR coyote brush do have bare zones.  

I speculate that a smallish-stand-alone chamise bush just can't provide the cover that large patches can.  That's why small bushes don't have a bare zone--if you're a mouse, there's no protection.  But a big stand of any kind of chaparral brush will do:  chamise, coyote bush, or even manzanita (another common California chaparral bush).  


The Google Earth photo (from March, 2013) shows this gap effect quite clarly.  Each of these clumps of bushes (some are chamise, some are coyote brush) has a small zone around each that clearly shows the effect of either the allopathic effects of chamise, or the herb grazing effects of small mammals near the bushes.  (Note also the change in the color of the soil near the bottom of the image; it really does change to a very light color down there.  I checked it out in person--this isn't an artifact, it's really a color shift.)    


And, if you look at many of the clumps of bushes, you can see a pretty clear effect of the presence (or absence) of a bare zone depending on the size of the clump of bushes. 


Bare zones seem to vary by bush clump size (and not by what kind of bush it is). These clumps are all taken from the area just to the north of the satellite photo shown above.  The 3 on the right, being fairly small, show no bare zone.

Once the clump gets below a certain size, the bare zone seems to disappear.  (Note that I haven't field-checked this, but I'll run up there this week and measure some of the bare zone widths to see if this really holds. More data when I have some to report.)  


Search Lessons


What I found so interesting about the comment thread this week is that Regular Researcher Remmij first found one explanation for the gap ("Shrub cover subsequently increases numbers of rabbits and small mammals (and birds too) that reduce herbaceous vegetation and favor shrub development [25,54]. Thus, well-established coyotebrush stands generally have depauperate understories [30].")   

Remmij's quotation is from Point Reyes National Seashore and North District of Golden Gate National Recreation Area (N.R.A.), Fire Management Plan: Environmental Impact Statement (2004), and leads directly to the "animals in the bush are causing the bare zone" interpretation.  

But then everyone seized on the allelopathic effect for chamise, probably because that's the first explanation that pops to the front when you do the obvious search.   But note that this is true only for chamise, and doesn't hold for coyote brush and other plants in the area.  


I suspect that what ALSO happened is a kind of piling-on: we all saw the first explanation (allelopathy) and thought "that must be it."  

If that's what happened (and I'm curious about your thoughts, Regular SearchResearchers), then this is an example of confirmation bias at work.  That is, the tendency (when doing research) to latch onto a plausible explanation and then search for reinforcing evidence.  

1. Be careful about confirmation bias!  In particular... 

2. Look for another explanation, or at least another point of view.  In this case, it turned out that allelopathy IS a real thing, but it's probably not what's going on here.  I found the "animals cause the bare zone" story because I noticed that these articles were all a few years old.  So I looked around a bit more and found... 

3.  It's a good idea to find a recent reference to see if current belief is the same as older beliefs.  And in this case, they weren't.  Botanical thinking had changed since the first allelopathic explanations were written.  


Sorry this took so long to publish, but I was busy reading and having a great time looking for examples of this effect.  

Hope you had as good a time as I did with this Challenge.  

This week's Challenge will come out tomorrow (Thursday).  


Search on!